Solutions

Pension vs. 401k: Defined Benefit vs. Defined Contribution

Pension vs 401k: the key difference is who takes on the risk. A pension, formally known as a defined benefit plan, is an employer-funded retirement plan. It guarantees a specific monthly income for life based on your years of service and salary history.

Person at a laptop taking notes on pension vs 401k options

Pension vs 401k: Who Carries the Risk

A 401(k), by contrast, is a defined contribution plan. The employee contributes from each paycheck, and investment returns aren’t guaranteed. Your account balance determines what you can spend in retirement.

In short, pensions shift investment and longevity risk to the employer. A 401(k) places those risks on you. Pensions are also increasingly rare outside of government and union employment.

How an Annuity Differs From a Pension

An annuity is a financial product purchased from an insurance company. It converts a lump sum into a guaranteed income stream, working somewhat like a pension you create yourself.

Both provide guaranteed income. However, an annuity is a purchase rather than an employer benefit, and the terms vary widely.

For retirees with a pension, choosing a lump sum or monthly payments is one of their most consequential financial decisions. At Moore Invested, we help clients evaluate pension payout options alongside their other income sources. Together, we determine the most advantageous strategy.